24 Feb 2011
Sample Essay: Apply Theory of Marx and Durkheim to State of the Union Speech
The American society has been realized to be a part of the new age nations of development and expansive progress. Even during the time of the financial issues and problems in the worldwide scope, the world looked through carefully as to how the nation would actually be able to manifest its operative competitiveness as it faces economic downfall. At present, the country’s President claims that the advancements have already been done and the accomplishment of development and recovery has been realized true. In his State of the Union Speech, he further points out specific guidelines that are better able to outline the different progressive approaches the country is expected to take towards defining the future of America. In the discussion herein, a definition of the themes of the speech presented by the President himself shall be identified and analyzed based on the theories of Durkheim and Marx about social development, capitalism and labor issues.
The State of the Union Speech of 2011
Understanding Its Idealisms through Durkheim’s Theories of Social Development
America is the cradle of development and the home of the free people. This is what President Barack Obama repeatedly mentioned in his speech during the State of the Union in 2011. He pointed out how through the years, the American society has become the source of inspiration and hope for many people, both the Americans themselves and the immigrants who come in the country. In his speech, he pointed out four important themes of focus which he imposes as the basic considerations that the American society must give attention to at present. What are these particular themes? One is the Nature Unity. Herein, he discusses the different forms of developmental factors that could assist America in its growth. One of which is the existence of immigrants in the country who share the responsibility of boosting up the nation’s economy through their labor. In his words, he imposes the need to stop putting too much stress on these individuals as they too, as part of the “free nation” deserves to be compensated well through giving them the education they need to be more productive and become an asset to the country’s growth more than what they already are. He tends to stop the idealism of Displaced Peasantry that is described as the massive effect of industrialization where workers are paid less for what they are actually putting forth (pp 700-717 taken notes). The President then points out that it is just right to give everyone a fair chance on the life that they deserve based on the effort that they are willing to put forth. To fix the situation, the application of the options of organic society could be taken into consideration. How could this be applied? As the president pointed out, the Tucson tragedy has marked this year’s American history as the people of different ages, color and perception in life get together to think of what has happened even to a young nine year old girl [along with all the others who died that day] who simply wanted to be a part of the movement towards her country’s development. Herein, the President points out how America is a family that needs to function with the help of everyone else taking their own role into serious consideration.
Another aspect of the speech focuses on the economy. This part of the discussion focused upon the need of creating more jobs, innovating businesses and welcoming more investors from all around the globe. Obama hopes to empower the industry and not to increase competition among the capitalists who are to entre in the country as per suggested in the idea of the theory that when capitalists compete, they reduce the skill of the workers, they introduce new machines for higher production rate; thus resulting to heightened unemployment rate (pp 480-481, taken notes). Instead of making them compete with each other, the President hopes to establish camaraderie among these capitalists hence assuming their capability to increase the number of job positions opened to for public appreciation.
The third aspect discussed is that of the welfare and education of the people. The common idealism of the Organic Solidarity depends on the people being closely balanced together and their role specifically defined by their desire to become a part of the growth of the society. As it is said by Durkeheim, organic solidarity is based on the complementary differences between the teachers and the students and how they make those differences work towards the benefits of everyone else (pp 157 taken notes). Through this, the President hopes to pursue programs that would not simply educate the students and the people with basic skills but would empower them with great consideration to honing their skills to make them more productive for the nation’s benefit and their own satisfaction as well.
The fourth and the most common among all the different State of the Union Speeches is that of the pursuance of the development of world leadership, whereas the president hopes to created a unified society as lead by the American desire to promote peace among all nations. The idea of imposing progress through unity is not a new idea anymore as this has been described by Durkheim as the oxygen of the social system as he points out that social cohesion for the sake of developing morality among all nations is necessary to put forth “world function” into a realized state (pp 40 Taken notes). Truthfully, it could be realized that the desire of the President is not only to establish America as a nation for the Americans, but a nation that stands as the epitome of hope for all the people of the world.
Understanding President Obama’s Thoughts of the American Future
Through the Thinking of Karl Marx
Communism or Capitalism: which is the real key to social solidarity? The President of the United States says neither. Instead, President Obama points out the fact that the key to social development and national recovery from the past challenges that the country has dealt with is the people of the nation. Regardless of their race or their origin, so long as they can empower the American community and economy, they are supposed to be regarded important by the government. There were four particular aspects of attention that the President mentioned in the speech. The four themes include education, nature unity, economy and world leadership.
He hoped to make the best out of the American society through developing the educational system of the nation that is directed towards all the people of the country. Marx practically hoped of assuming the idea of improving the society through developing the capability of the people to use their labor efforts more (pp 147 Taken Notes). And doing so requires of the people to be properly trained through education. This is what the President hopes to promote as part of his discussion. While education is improved, it is expected that employment rate opens up to further growth hence ending the struggle of unemployment among individuals in the society. This is in complete opposition to Marx’s promotion of social peasantry where he seeks to develop a system that would make the people work whether or not they are being compensated properly for their effort (pp 700-717 Taken Notes). The President hopes to create natural unity in the nation through manifesting the capability of each individual to realize the kind of satisfaction that they deserve in par with the work that they are willing to offer in exchange of a means of living. Yes, it is believed by the president that creating a more sufficient society that is able to make the best out of every opportunity there is for growth is dependent on the satisfaction that the people realize.
To finish up his speech, the President gears towards the development of world leadership that is expected to make a definitive effect on the process by which economic stability is supported by the government. He repeatedly called to his fellow democrats and the other party of the republicans to work together in unity towards developing oneness in the leadership that should accompany the American society towards prosperity and growth. Unlike the course taken by competitive capitalism as per mentioned in Marx’s ideas of a strong society based on achievements of the higher classes and the sustenance of the lower class (pp 556-573, Taken Notes), the President of America hopes to empower everyone and give everyone a chance to realize their worth in the society. How could this be done? He simply hopes to call on the possibility of establishing workable camaraderie among the capitalists and the cooperative relationship that they establish not only with the government but the people as well; and this assumption of roles and situations goes vice-versa. Through the assumptions of development that the President has outlined in his speech, it could be realized how he simply hopes to affect the being of each individual who has become a part of the American society thus pursuing a path towards peace and unity in the whole nation as they face the new era of world industrial revolution.
References:
Mark and Engel’s Theory of History. History as a Succession of Modes of Production.
Durkheim’s Future Good Society. Natural Abilities and External Conditions.